BRUSSELS - Vulnerable Bulgarian women are coming to Belgium and the Netherlands to live with elderly people who prefer to stay at home rather than go to a nursing home. They will care for these elderly people during the last years or months of their lives. This research is a case study of the practices of Seniorcare24, a major provider of these services in the Low Countries, and the fate of the caregivers seconded by this company from Bulgaria.
The investigation shows that these women are severely exploited. The wages they receive are far below the Belgian minimum wage, if they are paid at all. It is also common for the women to work long hours with far too little rest. There are also cases of outright harassment by the entrepreneurs behind the company.
The investigation also reveals how the owners manage to largely evade supervision and legal liability by splitting their business across national borders into several legal entities.
Finally, the journalists note that while this type of care is particularly popular with the elderly and has the potential to be a win-win situation for both clients and carers, there is a lack of an appropriate legal framework with adequate safeguards to protect the rights of the carers themselves.
The research received a lot of attention and inspired parliamentary questions in both the Flemish and Dutch parliaments.
This project (VTM) has been nominated for the Belfius Prize 2019.
ONLINE
- Fraude met Bulgaarse vrouwen in de ouderenzorg (BE) – Knack, 30 May 2018
- Fraude met Bulgaarse vrouwen in ouderenzorg: zwoegen voor 400 euro per maand (BE) – Knack, 30 May 2018
- Bulgarians Accused of Practicing Modern Slavery in Senior Care in Belgium (BG) – Bivol, 30 May 2018
- Българи експлоатирали домашни асистенти за възрастни в Белгия (BG) – Bivol, 30 May 2018
- Onderzoek Uitbuiting in de zorg (NL) – De Groene Amsterdammer, 13 June 2018
- Непосилна грижа срещу 400 евро на месец (BG) – 24 Chasa, 14 June 2018
- How to get around the EU posted workers directive – EUObserver, 20 June 2018
TV
- Trailer
- Fraude met bejaardenzorg, (BE), Telefacts (VTM), 30 mei 2018
- TELEFACTS ONTHULT VORM VAN MODERNE SLAVERNIJ (BE)- VTM, 30 May 2018
- Watch the full documentary here, Telefacts (VTM), 30 May 2018
Secondaire publicaties
- ‘Moderne slavernij’ in de Belgische ouderenzorg (BE) – De Standaard, 30 mei 2018
- Peeters zit samen met Bulgaren over fraude met zorg (BE) – De Tijd, 31 mei 2018
- Jo Vandeurzen: ‘Activiteiten Bulgaars zorgbedrijf moeten eindigen’ – Knack, 30 mei 2018
- Fraude met Bulgaarse vrouwen in Belgische ouderenzorg – despecialist.eu, 30 mei 2018
- Importante fraude dans les soins aux seniors impliquant une société bulgare – Le journal du Médicin, 30 mei 2018
- Fraude dans les soins aux seniors: Kris Peeters travaille avec les autorités bulgares – Ciel FM, 30 mei 2018
- Esclavagisme moderne et arnaque dans une société de services pour seniors – 7sur7, 30 mei 2018
- Quand une société bulgare arnaque les seniors belges (et leurs soignants) – Paris Match, 30 mei 2018
- Fraude dans les soins aux seniors: Kris Peeters travaille avec les autorités bulgares – RTBF, 30 mei 2018
- Bulgarians Accused of Practicing Modern Slavery in Senior Care in Belgium (BG) – Bivol, 30 mei 2018
- Българи експлоатирали домашни асистенти за възрастни в Белгия – (BG) – Bivol, 30 mei 2018
Impact
- Een plenaire debat in het Vlaams Parlement – Vlaamparlement.be, 30 mei 2018
- Knack, “Jo Vandeurzen: Activiteiten Bulgaars zorgbedrijf moeten eindigen”, 30.05.2018, https://www.tijd.be/nieuws/archief/Peeters-zit-samen-met-Bulgaren-over-fraude-met-zorg/10017224
- Beweging.net, “Hard optreden tegen uitbuiting in ouderenzorg”, 30.05.2018, https://www.beweging.net/algemeen/nieuws/24-nieuwsberichten/3051-commercialisering-zorgsector-geen-geldgewin-boven-kwaliteit
- Interpellatie, Gemeenschappelijke Gemeenschapscommissie, Commissie Sociale Zaken, 24.10.2018, http://weblex.irisnet.be/data/arccc/biq/2018-19/00003/images.pdf
- Schriftelijke vragen Tweede Kamer, 14.06.2018,https://www.tweedekamer.nl/kamerstukken/kamervragen/detail?id=2018Z11388&did=2018D34021
- Minister De Jonge, Beantwoording Kamervragen over het artikel ‘Trillende handen aan het bed’ (uitbuiting in de thuiszorg), 21.08.2018, https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/kamerstukken/2018/08/21/beantwoording-kamervragen-over-het-artikel-%E2%80%98trillende-handen-aan-het-bed%E2%80%99-uitbuiting-in-de-thuiszorg
- Minister De Jonge, Kamerbrief aan de Tweede Kamer over het bericht in de Groene Amsterdammer over de behandeling van Bulgaars personeel door zorgbedrijf “Care4you”, 21.08.2018, https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/kamerstukken/2018/08/21/kamerbrief-over-bulgaarse-bedrijven-die-ondermaatse-inwonende-thuiszorg-aanbieden
- Zorgvisie, “De Jonge: Bulgaarse zorgbedrijven moeten worden aangepakt”, 22.08.2018, https://www.zorgvisie.nl/de-jonge-bulgaarse-zorgbedrijven-moeten-worden-aangepakt/
- Bivol, Bulgarians Accused of Practicing Modern Slavery in Senior Care in Belgium, 30.05.2018, https://bivol.bg/en/bulgarians-accused-of-practicing-modern-slavery-in-senior-care-in-belgium.html
- Bivol, БългариексплоатиралидомашниасистентизавъзрастнивБелгия, 30.05.2018, https://bivol.bg/seniorcare24.html
- 24Chasa, 31.05.2018, “Πoзcлĸдвoтбългopcaидpyжĸcтвo вБĸлгиязo тpyдeвo ĸacплeoтoция”, https://www.24chasa.bg/novini/article/6890855?fbclid=IwAR3W10SZG_-SjIF1yv-Q0L1zAF0WztzMRGt7dbkON0X8QCFlSUCARFvfmmk
- Dnes.bg, “СестритеМюлервнеизвестност! Носновафирма”, 21.06.2018, https://www.dnes.bg/eu/2018/06/21/sestrite-miuler-v-neizvestnost-no-s-nova-firma.380033
- 24Chasa, “Pĸcтpитĸ Kюлĸp cмĸнятcиcтĸмoтo, c aeятe eтгeдинимoмятбългopaи, eбвинявoтAвpeпo”, 15.06.2018, https://www.24chasa.bg/novini/article/6915311?fbclid=IwAR1rff5tPNpJihAE54DVT0eP1RiE-6DyI8z7E9Ye0TGOZacSqVe63Zp8GHE
- Antwoord Bulgaarse Minister Sociale Zaken na vraag in het parlement, 27.06.2018 http://www.parliament.bg/pub/PK/309635854-06-823.pdf?fbclid=IwAR1-BYTsg4WtXSEuzlUJg2Pt5yC1i29Uv6q_7DPWHpc0NUH3XHdH1Hjeu_0
- Officiële mededeling van de Bulgaarse minister van buitenlandse zaken, 28.06.2018, http://www.parliament.bg/bg/topical_nature/30025?fbclid=IwAR0zpxaSl90f3LHXffaJPLXALzioHGTRXYUjGvrC1jSDGxWnzmDvpWFrxJ0
- Baricada, “МВнР не се вълнува от скандала с експлоатираните българки в Белгия”, 29.06.2018, https://baricada.org/2018/06/29/skandal-rabotnici-belgium/ (artikel over reactie minister Buitenlandse Zaken)